NEWARK (NJ)
STAR-LEDGER REVIEW by Raymond Frey - Will
Durant (1885-1981) was perhaps the most widely read
historian of the twentieth century. In 1926, he
published a book of brief essays on the great
philosophers called The Story of
Philosophy. The smash best seller
launched the fledgling publisher Simon and Schuster
as a major force in publishing and introduced more
people to philosophy than any other book.
Eventually
Durant became disenchanted with the puzzles and
paradoxes of philosophy, and longed to write a
comprehensive history of civilization. In 1935,
he embarked on a project to chronicle its entire
scope and sweep; The Story of
Civilization grew into a work of 11 massive
volumes and took forty-six years to complete.
In
later volumes he shared the title page with his wife
Ariel, who increasingly contributed to this enormous
task during their sixty-eight years of
marriage. Every one was a bestseller, and
volume seven, Rousseau and Revolution,
won a Pulitzer Prize in 1968.
Durant
employed a narrative writing style he called
"integral" history. Believing that
the usual method of writing history in distinct
sections--political history, economic history,
religious history, history of philosophy, history of
science--did not capture the unity and flow of human
life, and he instead wanted to present history as
"one complex, moving picture."
Using thousands of slips of paper to organize the
research--and writing in longhand--Durant would
produce a finished manuscript every three or four
years for 40 years, from 1935 to
1975.
These
efforts were scorned by many academic historians, who
accused them of shoddy scholarship and an
over-reliance on secondary sources. One
particularly blistering review said that in their
books the Durants attempted "to reduce
everything to a softminded pulp."
Defenders
said some scholars failed to understand that these
works were intended to introduce non-specialist
readers to the past, and any failings in scholarship
were to be expected in such a monumental work and
were of minor significance.
Ultimately,
in spite of the criticisms, the superb organization
of their books, combined with and eminently readable
style, won the Durants millions of fans.
At
Will Durant's death at 96, in 1981, his personal
papers were dispersed among relatives, collectors,
and archive houses. Among these, scholar John
Little recently discovered the previously unknown
manuscript of Heroes of History completed
shortly Durant died. The original intention was
to produce a script for a television series, but with
failing health he decided to write 23 brief essays,
of which he completed 21, to serve as an abbreviated
version of The Story of Civilization.
Durant
was always more interested in great people than great
events. He once wrote that "history
operates in events but through persons; these are the
voice of events, the flesh and blood upon which
events fall."
This
book follows that same pattern, as he weaves the
historical narrative around the heroes of the
past. Durant had a gift for summary. His
essay on the life and times of Jesus, for example,
takes just eleven pages to tell this complex and
moving story from birth to resurrection with amazing
detail and clarity.
Other
excellent essays are those of Julius Caesar-- "a
great statesman (who) was not above vanity;"
Leonardo da Vinci, who Durant calls "the most
fascinating figure of the Renaissance;" and the
Christian reformer Martin Luther: "The man who
was to have more influence upon subsequent history
than anyone but Copernicus and Columbus."
He
carefully sets the historical, cultural, and
political scene before presenting his heroes upon the
stage of history. This combination of biography
and intellectual history is one of Durant's
hallmarks, and it works exceedingly well in this
book. He also frequently speaks to his audience
in the first person, as if reminiscing with the
reader after a lifetime spent in chronicling the
past.
With
this last book, Durant posthumously comes full
circle. In The Story of Philosophy,
he succeeded, in one book, in bringing the ideas of
great philosophers within the reach of the average
person. Similarly, Heroes of
History makes some of history's greatest
personalities vivid to general readers.
This
invitation to the grandeur of the past will surely
send many back to Durant's earlier works to learn
more.
Raymond
Frey is Associate Professor of History and Dean of
Faculty at Centenary College in Hackettstown.
He is the author of William James Durant, An
Intellectual Biography, published by Mellen
Press.
WALL
STREET JOURNAL REVIEW by Roger Kimball - "No
man is a hero to his valet," said a 17th-century
French society hostess. "But not,"
riposted the philosopher Hegel more than a century
later, "Because the hero is not a hero, but
because the valet is a valet."
In
fact, Hegel was unfair to valets, who as a class are
at least as great-souled as German philosophers.
(Consider Jeeves.) The taste, the need, for
heroes is inversely proportional to a society's level
of self-satisfaction. If we have heard a great
deal about heroes since September 11, it is at least
partly because our complacency was assaulted that day
along with the Twin Towers. And just as recent
events have called forth heroic acts, they may also
reawaken our capacity to value heroes, which is part
of a larger capacity to value greatness.
Complacent
ages neither cultivate nor willingly acknowledge
greatness. In 1840, when Thomas Carlyle
delivered his lectures "On Heroes, Hero-Worship,
and the Heroic in History," he could count on a
robust appetite for greatness among his
readers. The history of the world, Carlyle
wrote, is "at bottom the History of the Great
Men who have worked" in it. For Carlyle
and his readers greatness sparked emulation.
"We cannot look, however imperfectly, upon a
great man without gaining something by him. He
is the living light-fountain, which it is good and
pleasant to be near."
Our
own age is quite different. In recent years we
have been favored with a great deal of "history
from below" -- that is, history detailing the
experience of workers, housewives, servants,
criminals and even madmen. This
close-to-the-ground perspective often entails an
impatience with greatness, even a disapproval of it,
since it is the great, presumably, who oppress those
beneath them. In the wake of September 11, I
suspect we will be subjected to rather less of this
reductive formula.
Instead,
there is bound to be a renaissance of interest in
heroes. The republication of Gustav Schwabs
"Gods and Heroes of Ancient Greece" will
speak to that interest, as will "Heroes of
History," Will Durants posthumously
published compilation of highlights from "The
Story of Civilization," the 11-volume panorama
of world history that he and his wife, Ariel,
published over the course of some 50 years.
When I
was in graduate school, it was fashionable to look
down on the Durants -- without, of course, actually
reading them. Their work was thought to be
superficial and, even worse, naively
affirmative. But even its detractors could not
deny that it possessed a sweep and robustness of
which even Carlyle would approve. "Heroes
of History" was Will Durant's effort to trace in
one short volume a series of cultural peaks. He
managed to complete 21 out of a projected 23 chapters
before his death in 1981, at age 96.
"Heroes
of History" is a lesson in the diversity of
greatness. Durant marches briskly across the
pages of history -- India from Buddha to Indira
Ghandi, the classical world from Pericles to Nero,
Christian Europe from Augustine to the Reformation --
holding up for our admiration the intrigues and
exploits of soldiers, saints, scientists, statesmen
and scribes. His heroes are men of genius,
energy and will, not necessarily rectitude.
Writing
about Alexander the Great, Durant registers his
drunkenness, promiscuity and cruelty but also the
amazing gifts -- the charisma, military acumen and
physical skill -- that allowed Alexander to conquer
most of the known world, repulsing with 30,000 men
the 600,000 amassed by Darius III. "We
admire him (as we admire Napoleon)," Durant
writes, "Because he stood alone against half the
world, and because he encourages us with the thought
of the incredible power that lies potential in the
individual soul."
True
enough, but it is well to remember that the exalted
word "hero" is often coupled with the worst
turns of fate. "Show me a hero," F.
Scott Fitzgerald wrote, "and I will write you a
tragedy." When Emerson, in "The Uses
of Great Men," said that "every hero
becomes a bore at last," he forgot that most
heroes do not live to enjoy "at last."
Mr.
Kimball's latest book is Experience Against
Reality (Ivan R. Dee).
FORT WORTH
STAR-TELEGRAM REVIEW by Jack Z. Smith - If you're a dyed-in-the-wool,
nose-in-the-air literary snob, or a passionless,
just-give-me-the-facts professor of world history,
Will Durant's Heroes of History may not be the book
for you.
Or, at least, you
would certainly pretend that it isn't.
But if you're a six
pack-and-cheeseburger bloke such as myself - someone
whom literary critics might sniffily refer to as a
"general reader" of history - you'll
treasure Durant's 329-page book subtitled "A
Brief History of Civilization From Ancient Times to
the Dawn of the Modern Age." It's an
entertaining, informative and passionate stroll
through select portions of history, ranging from
ancient Egypt to the Italian Renaissance. Heroes
offers revealing glimpses of such history makers as
Confucius, Euripides, Alexander the Great, Jesus,
Julius and Augustus Caesar, Lorenzo de Medici,
Leonardo da Vinci, Michelangelo, Martin Luther,
Ignatius Loyola, Queen Elizabeth I, William
Shakespeare and Francis Bacon.
Durant died in 1981,
at age 96. He and his wife, Ariel (who died 13 days
before him), wrote The Story of Civilization, an
11-volume masterpiece that consumed 46 years of their
lives. One volume, Rousseau and Revolution, won the
Pulitzer Prize in 1968.
Durant was nearing
completion of Heroes of History when he died. The
manuscript was found 20 years later in the garage of
a granddaughter's home.
Millions of people
have enjoyed the Durants' works, which give an
overview of more than 100 centuries of history and
were written for broad consumption. While some
historians and literary critics have questioned the
Durants' scholarship - getting to the point has never
been a strong suit of most historian-writers - Will
Durant's awesome range of knowledge is manifest in
Heroes of History.
The book has drawn
some semi-justifiable criticism for being overly
Eurocentric and for paying insufficient attention to
women (though there are some absorbing insights into
the women of ancient Egypt and Elizabeth I, who ruled
England during its heady days in the late 16th
century). But Heroes' attributes far outweigh its
shortcomings. Whether describing the personal traits
that made Alexander the Great so great, or explaining
how the confessional box of Catholic churches was
darkened so that priests would not feel tempted by
comely penitents, Durant writes in an engaging style
that makes history real and fascinating - and whets
your appetite for more.
THE VIRGINIAN-PILOT
(Norfolk, Va). REVIEW By Barbara Spigel - In 1935, Will and Ariel Durant
published the first book of their 11-volume work,
"The Story of Civilization." In 1977, at
the age of 92, four years before his death, Durant
decided to publish an abbreviated version, to be
called "Heroes of History." Some 20 years
later the unfinished manuscript was discovered by
John Little, the executor of the Durant Literary
Estate. Durant completed 21 of 23 intended chapters
of this extraordinary book, which introduces history
as a form of philosophy.
A major literary event,
"Heroes of History" explores the
accomplishments of ancient China, of India, Greece,
Rome and medieval Europe, and emphasizes the key
figures dealt with at greater length in "The
Story of Civilization."
Durant was possibly the
best-known teacher of history and philosophy of his
generation. His wife, Ariel, collaborated with him on
The Story of Civilization, and on a
companion book, The Lessons Of History,
which they called, A survey of human
experience.
Winner of the Pulitzer Prize
and recipient of the Medal of Freedom, Will Durant
maintained that history is not merely a "warning
reminder of man's follies and crimes
as
Voltaire and Gibbon concluded, but is rather
the attempt to achieve philosophical
perspective by a study of events in time.
The heroes of these events --
saints and statesmen; inventors and scientists;
poets, artists, philosophers and musicians -- changed
the face of civilization and thus history. Their
efforts, their skill and their vision renew our faith
in ourselves as they remind us of our potential for
greatness.
Durant contends that we cannot
Shape our future without knowledge of the past; to
know the past is to have confidence in the future.
One of his major thrusts is that history is a series
of recurring sequences, an ebb and flow of morality
such that, "A period of pagan license is
followed by an age of puritan restraint and moral
discipline."
He reminds us that 300 years
before Plato, Heracleitus was fascinated by what
seemed to him obvious: that change is universal,
energy is indestructible and everlasting. He leaves
us wondering how much lower moral and ethical
behavior has to go before the next disciplinary
turnaround.
For Durant, man is indeed the
measure of all things, and his insights into
history's most extraordinary figures are illustrated
by his estimated of Leonardo da Vinci, who, for all
his limitations and incompletions was, "The
fullest man of the Renaissance, perhaps of all
time."
There are times when the reader
may wonder why Durant includes certain things and
omits others. But his judgments are shrewd and
incisive, his points are crisp and clear, and he
never patronizes the reader. Thanks to his easy,
uncomplicated style, the achievements of the past
become strikingly clear.
Durant is one of the most
influential of a growing number of voices reminding
us that without a knowledge of the past there is no
wisdom to guide us to the future, Perhaps it's time
we took note of the fact.
Engrossing, informative and
thoroughly enjoyable, "Heroes of History"
is that rare book that invites superlatives. It's
also a fitting tribute to Durant, 20 years after his
death.
BOOK - THE MAGAZINE FOR
READING LIFE REVIEW by
Eric Wargo - Durant, a Pulitzer Prize-
winning historian, conceived of a series of audio
lectures condensing his eleven-volume opus, The
Story of Civilization, for a modern audience; he
was working on the project at the time of his death
in 1981. The manuscript, lost until last winter, is
being published for the first time. It begins with
the great teachers of the OrientConfucius and
the Buddhaand moves through the best
philosophers, poets and statesmen of Egypt, Greece
and Rome, through the heroes of the Old Testament and
New, and culminates with the guiding lights of the
Renaissance and ReformationLeonardo da Vinci,
Martin Luther, William Shakespeare. It's history's
greatest hits, you could say. That Durant viewed
history as "philosophy teaching by
examples" is clear on every page: These aren't
just familiar textbook facts but the gripping
anecdotes of extraordinary figures, their monumental
choices and profound insights brought to life by a
great storyteller.
BOOKLIST
REVIEW by Jay Freeman - Before his
death in 1981, esteemed historian Durant had
completed 21 of a projected 23 chapters of this work,
which was intended to serve as a condensed version of
his landmark 11-volume series, The Story of
Civilization (1935). The wonderfully lucid and
almost poetic prose that characterized that series
remains here. As always, Durant displays keen
insights and passionate admiration for the
accomplishments of varied civilizations, including
those of ancient China, India, Rome, and medieval
Europe. He is at his best when he analyzes those
individuals who contributed mightily to the glories
of their civilizations. Figures as diverse as Buddha,
Confucius, Jesus, and Lorenzo de Medici are treated
with both reverence and realism. For the general
reader, this work will be both enjoyable and
informative, providing a basis for those who wish to
delve even deeper into the history of some of these
civilizations. Jay Freeman Copyright ©
American Library Association. All rights reserved
AMAZON.COM
REVIEW by Gregory MacNamee - "In
this collection of biographical and historical
sketches drawn from an unfinished manuscript
discovered two decades after his death, Will Durant
celebrates historical figures whose examples
demonstrate that humans can, "when sufficiently
inspired, rise to levels of greatness with the gods
themselves."
Durant
(1885-1981), the principal author of The Story of
Civilization, saw history as a branch of philosophy,
and he peppered his stories of great historical
actors and events with moral lessons and observed
patterns....These brief lectures, touching on leaders
and innovators, such as Buddha, Marcus Aurelius,
Leonardo da Vinci, and Martin Luther, afford him
plenty of opportunity to reflect on the meaning of
the past and to offer models for his readers to study
and emulate...fans of Durant's brand of sweeping
narrative history will enjoy having these final words
from the master.
PUBLISHER'S
WEEKLY REVIEW - This posthumous
collection of essays by a Pulitzer Prize winner
targets those who don't know much about history.
Durant, who died in 1981 at the age of 96, is best
known for the multivolume history of the world,
"The Story of Civilization," he wrote with
his wife, Ariel. In these recently discovered essays,
he again displays his talents for popularizing
history, most notably a remarkable ability to
summarize complicated thoughts and events in a few
succinct words: this book of "heroes"
covers figures ranging from Nero to Shakespeare and
spans more than 2,000 years. After the first three
essays, on Confucius, Buddha and Egypt's Ikhnaton,
Durant turns his attention to Greece, Rome and the
rise of the West. He devotes several chapters to
Jesus and his followers over the centuries, asserting
that that the study of religion "sheds more
light upon the nature and possibilities of man and
government than the study of almost any other subject
or institution open to human inquiry."...This
book is likely to find a wide audience among those
looking for an introduction to world history.
FROM
BARNES & NOBLE - Appearing 20 years
after his death at the age of 96, Heroes of
History is an abbreviated version of his
universally acclaimed 11-volume epic, The Story of
Civilization. Durant ably guides the reader
through thousands of years of human history -- all
the way from Confucius to the 18th century. Thus, Heroes
of History is a wonderful tribute to the
legendary Durant, and a treat for history fans
everywhere.
For
more on the new book and other information on coming
projects please read the interview with editor John
Little by clicking here.
.